(start around 2 minutes in and watch through replay review)
That’s right! “The runner’s knee was down on the goal line and the ball was thrown from the end zone. The result of the play is a safety.”
As soon as I heard the imbecile say it, I jumped out of my seat ready to riot. Let’s break this down one part at a time here.
Right off the bat, “The runner’s knee was down on the goal line” would mean “the ball was thrown from the endzone” does not matter. You, yourself, just admitted he is “down” before he threw it so let’s take the second part out of the statement and try again.
“The runner’s knee was down on the goal line. The result of the play is a safety.”
Don’t know how I missed this at first, but let’s not ignore the fact that he refers to him as a “runner” as well. So (despite how comical it is) just completely ignore the player throwing the ball at the end of this play because he is admittedly down. This leaves us with just a good old fashioned punt return and “the result of this play is a safety” is wrong for multiple reasons.
- It does not matter “the runner’s knee was down on the goal line” – just where the ball was when the knee comes down.
- Because he fielded the ball in play and his momentum carried him backwards, the ball should be placed where he initially fielded it (between the 1- and 2-yard line). Think of this as forward progress so to speak – probably one of the first handful of things you learn in referee school.